Discussing Racial and Ethnic Differences in Health Care

A few items appeared this week touching on racial and ethnic differences in health care. We are focused on diversity at HFA, as we prepare for our 2009 teleconference on Diversity and End-of-Life Care.

First, the New Health Dialog Blog discussed a study that appeared in the September 10 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association, "Student Body Racial and Ethnic Composition and Diversity-Related Outcomes in US Medical Schools". The authors conclude "attending medical schools with high levels of racial and ethnic diversity may better prepare white medical students to care for minority patients." Analyzing over 20,000 web-based surveys from students graduated from 118 medical schools, the authors commented:

. . . white students attending more racially diverse medical schools rated themselves as better prepared than students at less diverse schools to care for racial and ethnic minority patients and had stronger attitudes about inadequate access to health care. . . . The associations of student body diversity appeared to be mediated by more positive interaction and perspective sharing among individuals from different backgrounds within medical schools. The association of student body diversity with white students' self-rated cultural competence was only observed when students perceived a more positive climate for interracial interaction and exchange of diverse perspectives.

Second, Pallimed reviewed a recent study from the Journal of Clinical Oncology on the racial and ethnic differences in advance care planning.

They found that Black and Hispanic patients were less likely to have an advance directive than white patients (and in this case much less likely: 80% vs 50%), were more religious, and were more likely to endorse life-prolonging treatment wishes even if had only a few days to live. Dishearteningly, only 30% of patients had had any sort of discussion with their physicians regarding end of life care - this finding did not differ between groups. Fewer Black and Hispanic patients acknowledged they were terminally ill compared to white patients, however such acknowledgment was associated with increased advance care planning in all groups. The really interesting finding is that differences in advance care planning persisted even after adjusting for demographic factors (age, education level, etc.), terminal illness awareness, religiosity, and preference for life-prolonging therapy when dying. Suggesting, that is, that these differences are either deeply cultural (and thus not as impacted by demographics, illness understanding, etc.) and/or related to how/the frequency with which clinicians bring up advance care planning with patients from different ethnic groups.

And last, the Oregon Center for Applied Science (ORCAS) is conducting surveys for a study funded by the National Institutes of Health. It is seeking people who identify as a racial or ethnic minority to receive $275 for using a new Family Caregiving Support program and completing four online surveys.

Eligible participants must:

* Care for an aging relative or friend with advanced illness or in need of assistance with daily tasks like bathing, eating, dressing, walking, etc.

* Have an email address and access to a computer with a high-speed Internet connection.

* Read and understand English.

Only one person per household may participate in this study.

Visit the survey site here.